BUYER ANSWER

First Choice vs Commercial Grade: Specifying Stone Without Surprises

Every stone quotation carries an implicit grade question: is the container priced to look like the sample photos, or priced to fill a floor at a budget? Writing the grade into the specification is what turns that question into a controlled decision. First Choice (Grade A) in procurement terms: colour and veining consistent across the batch within the range of the approved photos; blocks sound, without fissures at working surfaces; tiles calibrated to thickness tolerance, edges bevelled, faces polished to the agreed gloss. This is the grade our REF-numbered photo sets represent - what you approve is the range that ships. Commercial grade: structurally sound material that allows wider colour swing, visible fill marks, minor natural defects - spots, lines, shading that departs from the catalogue look. For tiles, an industry rule of thumb accepts a small percentage of pieces with minor technical imperfections. Commercial grade is not defective stone; it is a different price-quality boundary, and for warehouse floors, parking structures and back-of-house areas it is often the correct specification - the budget goes to area, not appearance. How to specify without surprises:
  1. Name the grade in the enquiry: "First Choice" or "Commercial" - not "good quality", which quotes to whoever is guessing.
  2. Anchor approval to photos, not words: the REF photo set is the batch record; approval by photo closes the colour question before cutting.
  3. Put acceptance criteria in the specification: what counts as a reject (visible fissure, chip beyond x mm, shade outside the approved range) and who inspects - our QC sheet reports against the criteria before loading.
  4. Split the order by grade where the project allows: First Choice in the lobby, Commercial in service areas - the quotation prices each line separately.
The grade you approve is written against the REF number, held through production, and reported in the pre-shipment inspection. Send the specification with the grade named - the quotation returns with the grade, photos and lead time in one working day.

Quick answers

Is Commercial grade cheaper for the same stone?

Yes - typically meaningfully below First Choice for the same material, because colour sorting and defect selection are the costly steps. The saving is real when appearance tolerance allows it.

Can I approve grade by photos before ordering?

That is the standard route - the REF photo set is shot against the actual batch, and approval is recorded against the REF number.

Does grade affect lead time?

First Choice runs on the standard schedule; Commercial can sometimes ship faster because selection is lighter.

Send drawings, get a REF quotation

Drawings, BOQ or a material reference - quotation with crate plan, grade and lead time within one working day.